The Unclear Impact

academia

I am reviewing a paper a despite the 1/2 page abstract and 1 page introduction, I still don’t understand what on Earth they are trying to do. no , but I still want to write something more concrete for the rejection.

replies
1
announces
0
likes
0

academia

@kristof Know that feeling. Normally, I ask myself if I am the problem or the paper, and then write something polite that the framing of the study is not convincing, scope unclear, or so...